Chocolate Pudding Jelly Belly jelly beans taste like chocolate, and they taste like pudding. So, if you love either of those things, this is the bean for you. Even if you only love one of those things, these beans will still serve you well. Chocolate Pudding Jelly Belly jelly beans are made with real chocolate, so chocolate lovers can dive right in with no regrets. No need for a spoon or little cup to enjoy this chocolate pudding taste.